Neither reclaimed nor new lumber is right for every job. Here is a side-by-side look at the things buyers usually weigh.
Appearance
Reclaimed wood carries nail holes, saw marks, checks and an aged surface, and its color varies from board to board. New lumber is uniform and predictable. If you want a consistent, clean look, new wood is easier. If you want character, reclaimed is hard to imitate.
Grain
Wood from older buildings often came from slower-grown trees and can show tighter growth rings than much modern plantation lumber. That is a general tendency, not a rule; every board should be judged on its own.
Workability
New lumber arrives at consistent sizes and is quick to work. Reclaimed wood may hide nails or bolts, may vary in size and usually needs more trimming. Plan for extra time and waste.
Stability
Wood that has been in a building for decades has usually dried well, but all wood still moves with changes in humidity. Let either kind acclimate before installation.
Structural Use
New structural lumber comes grade-stamped. Reclaimed wood used to carry loads needs grading by a qualified grader and approval from your engineer or building official.
Reuse
Reusing a board avoids cutting and milling a new one for the same job and keeps a useful material out of the waste stream. New lumber from responsibly managed forests is also a reasonable choice; the benefit of reclaimed is greatest when it is sourced locally and little of it is wasted.
Price
Pricing for both varies widely. Reclaimed wood is priced by quote from partner suppliers and depends on species, size, condition and processing.
Bottom Line
Use reclaimed wood where its look matters most: beams, mantels, accent walls, floors and furniture. Use new lumber where uniformity and quick installation matter more, such as hidden framing.